Comic Fury Webcomic Hosting - Secret Reviewer - Give a critique, get a critique!

You are not logged in. Log in, Register, More info
Forum > Critique > Secret Reviewer - Give a critique, get a critique!
Pages: [1] [2] [3] [4]

"Secret Reviewer - Give a critique, get a critique!", 16th Feb 2017, 6:10 PM #1
snuffysam

User avatar
Posts: 295
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th Feb 2014
A lot of us want a review of our comic, but all the critique threads are full.
Many of us want to write a review, but can't get to everyone who wants one.
Given this, I thought it would be a good idea to have a secret santa-like thread for critiques.

Simply ask to have your name + comic down on the list. Once we're ready to start, I'll put all the names into https://www.random.org/lists/, and keep pressing randomize until nobody has their own name. Then, I'll PM you with the person you should review. Once you're done with the review, post it in the thread, and wait for your secret reviewer to finish with yours!

Comics of ANY page length and with ANY content warnings are allowed- so be warned. If you absolutely do not want to review explicit content, just specify and I'll keep randomizing until you get a non-explicit comic.


Entries are now closed. Stay tuned for people's reviews!

When critiquing: Feel free to use whatever style you want- harsh, nice, humorous, RP, art-focused, writing-focused, etc. The only stipulation is that it MUST be two paragraphs long at the minimum.
(otherwise, I'm pretty sure a lot of people would put out one-word reviews just to do the minimum effort)

When being critiqued: Just remember that the review you get might not be the kind you want or need the most- but that is the point of a secret santa, after all.


For the list of people- I'm thinking 5 people at the minimum, 20 people maximum. Any less would be difficult to randomize properly, and any more would be difficult to keep track of.



1. snuffysam - Super Galaxy Knights Deluxe R (COMPLETE - Johnny Bullet - Princess Chroma)
2. JTige - Mundane Maria (COMPLETE - The Sovereigncy)
3. LeRenardRoux - The Wolf at Weston Court (COMPLETE - Just Another Day)
4. Xigirl - Lady Gamer Comics (no explicit)
5. Zor15 - The Birthmarks of the Dark World (COMPLETE - Nightlight)
6. nearmintmill - The Sovereigncy (COMPLETE - Blood and Claws)
7. craybest - Blood and Claws (COMPLETE - Super Galaxy Knights Deluxe R)
8. spidar - Death Child (COMPLETE - Crazies Inc.)
9. ProRevo128 - Just Another Day (COMPLETE - Totally Original Pokemon Nuzlocke Comic)
10. SunnySideUpSmile - Those Days So Long Ago (COMPLETE - Death Child)
11. SharpyTheYellowKirby - I'm Not Your Friend (COMPLETE - Re:Set)
12. Coolcatcomics - Eternal Night (COMPLETE - Lady Gamer Comics)
13. azureXtwilight - Re:Set (COMPLETE - Mundane Maria)
14. keltyzoid! - Nightlight (COMPLETE - The Wolf at Weston Court)
15. melaredblu - Princess Chroma (COMPLETE - Breath of Life)
16. Lt. Locust - Breath of Life (COMPLETE - Catihorn)
17. Rulerbrain - Crazies Inc. (COMPLETE - Birthmarks of the Dark World)
18. midnightpizza - totally original pokemon nuzlocke comic (COMPLETE - Those Days So Long Ago)
19. Epiale - Catihorn (COMPLETE - I'm Not Your Friend)
20. Toondoctor - Johnny Bullet (COMPLETE - Eternal Night)
_______________________
image
16th Feb 2017, 6:52 PM #2
Xigirl⚧

Posts: 91
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 15th Aug 2016
Location: The Lady Gamer Dimension
Me Comic!

Lady Gamer Comics

PM me when ya get dis.
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 6:59 PM #3
Zor15♀

User avatar
Posts: 251
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 18th Jul 2012
Location: The city of Murals
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 7:17 PM #4
snuffysam

User avatar
Posts: 295
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th Feb 2014
Both added!
_______________________
image
16th Feb 2017, 7:24 PM #5
LeRenardRoux♀
Sqaljjlmzonq
User avatar
Posts: 1584
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th Jul 2013
Location: at the bottom of a stair whose top is invisible with light
_______________________
image
"To you I am nothing more than a fox like a hundred thousand other foxes. But if you tame me, then we shall need each other. To me, you will be unique in all the world. To you, I shall be unique in all the world...."
16th Feb 2017, 7:28 PM #6
JTige♂

User avatar
Posts: 148
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 12th Oct 2016
Location: Ontario
Hey, this could be fun.

I humbly offer Mundane Maria to the mix.
_______________________
image
Click on this if you like wizards.
16th Feb 2017, 7:30 PM #7
nearmintmill♀

User avatar
Posts: 674
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 18th Feb 2016
Location: LB CA
sure. comic link is in my sig
16th Feb 2017, 7:42 PM #8
craybest♂

User avatar
Posts: 631
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 29th Aug 2012
Location: Santiago, Chile
what about the minimum number of pages and content type required in a comic for a critique? mine has just 7 pages so far XD (although 4 more as backup) and also has some pretty explicit sex.
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 8:00 PM #9
snuffysam

User avatar
Posts: 295
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th Feb 2014
Ooh good point, especially on the content type. I'll add a disclaimer to the OP, and ask the people who have already signed up if they're ok with that.
_______________________
image
16th Feb 2017, 8:07 PM #10
craybest♂

User avatar
Posts: 631
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 29th Aug 2012
Location: Santiago, Chile
thanks! I don't want to complicate things too much to you though >-<
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 9:41 PM #11
snuffysam

User avatar
Posts: 295
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th Feb 2014
Ok, I think I've got things sorted out. If someone doesn't want to review explicit content, I'll just keep randomizing until they don't have to review it.

As a side note... is this you signing up with your comic?
_______________________
image
16th Feb 2017, 10:14 PM #12
craybest♂

User avatar
Posts: 631
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 29th Aug 2012
Location: Santiago, Chile
if 7 pages is enough to ask for a critique, then yes :)
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 10:14 PM #13
craybest♂

User avatar
Posts: 631
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 29th Aug 2012
Location: Santiago, Chile
double post, sorry ;_;
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 10:19 PM #14
spidar

User avatar
Posts: 491
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 26th Jun 2016
Location: Cantabria
Count me in! With Death Child, please... C:
_______________________
Hats, hats, hats...
16th Feb 2017, 10:42 PM #15
ProRevo128♂

User avatar
Posts: 2139
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 17th Mar 2016
Location: March 17
This looks interesting! I think I'll throw my comic in here as well.

Link is my banner :D
_______________________
16th Feb 2017, 10:49 PM #16
SunnySideUpSmile⚧

User avatar
Posts: 1138
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 8th Nov 2016
Location: Under your Bed
I'm up for it. ^^ Those Days So Long Ago, link in signature. :D

Edit: Flags are language, sex, and violence, though the middle hasn't been totally introduced, just hints here and there, same goes for latter.
_______________________
image Sense & Sensibility is on hiatus.
image
16th Feb 2017, 10:50 PM #17
SharpyTheYellowKirby⚧

User avatar
Posts: 589
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 27th May 2014
Location: Setting His Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
Fuck it I'm in. Link in signature.
_______________________
image
16th Feb 2017, 10:52 PM #18
Coolcatcomics♂

User avatar
Posts: 2282
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 3rd Mar 2016
Location: your mom
ohh i want in!! add eternal night, link in sig :>
_______________________
i don't always make jokes but when i do they're not funny
image
image image image image
me being cool and handsome on other websites (advance at own risk)
17th Feb 2017, 12:07 AM #19
azureXtwilight

User avatar
Posts: 2592
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 18th Apr 2015
Location: Indonesia
_______________________
image
Updates Fridays, 11 AM PST
17th Feb 2017, 12:38 AM #20
keltyzoid!♂

User avatar
Posts: 4850
Referrals: 0
Registration date: 13th Feb 2015
this sounds fun. i need a sucker punch to the ego.

keltyzoid//Nightlight
_______________________
image
Forum > Critique > Secret Reviewer - Give a critique, get a critique!
Pages: [1] [2] [3] [4]