Forum > Critique > I'll read your comic for 5 minutes
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 12
"I'll read your comic for 5 minutes", 7th Aug 2022, 5:13 PM #1
💖💕 hate 💘 death 💝 kill 💞💗
User avatar
Sept 22 2022 UPDATE: I have 4 comics left in the queue, assuming I haven't accidentally skipped anyone else. Anyone is welcome to submit their comic, still taking new ones

Sept 8 2022 UPDATE: Still taking new comics. If you posted a while ago in the thread and think your comic got skipped, let me know.

----

I will read your comic for a minimum of 5 minutes and tell you what I think. If I'm hooked I might read more. This will likely not be a lengthy review as you will be getting my first impressions. This is meant to give an idea of what some rando might think when stumbling across your comic.

Warning: I am going to tell you if I do not like your comic, or if I think something looks off, or if I think something is gross. All content warning flags are ok, but no full on porn comics.

Impressions so far:
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 5:14 PM #2
🥔 Top Deg 🥔
User avatar
I bet you can only read because of those eyes you have. I offer Now Hiring to the impressions bin.
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 5:20 PM #3
User avatar
I don't have more than 5 mins of reading in mine even if you wanted more so please do and thank you
_______________________
image
7th Aug 2022, 5:20 PM #4
just 5 more minutes
User avatar
I’ll throw Dead or Alive in the ring, thanks for the chance :^)
_______________________
image
image
7th Aug 2022, 5:23 PM #5
Botanist
User avatar
ok, cf-c pls
_______________________
image
7th Aug 2022, 5:28 PM #6

User avatar
So only 5 minutes ...interesting. count me in ...please.
_______________________
image
Expect the unexpected. Never take anything for granted. Scrutinise everything. Be open-minded. Learn.

You gotta start thinking of backgrounds as a character all its own
-Andy G.
7th Aug 2022, 5:48 PM #7
💖💕 hate 💘 death 💝 kill 💞💗
User avatar
Now Hiring
You scoundrel, of course I read the whole thing.
art: gad dam you know what’s up. the perspective stuff, the curvy perspective stuff, wow
So this looks edgy, my kind of genre. I like Aisel. Pretty seamless introduction of the alien aspects of this universe. I will destroy everyone for being mean to Maks.

Eye of the Storm
Succinctly put: good shit.
Good horses! Most of the time I don't like hand-written text however this text is readable.
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 5:51 PM #8
User avatar
Please, look at Vápnthjófr saga!
_______________________
image
7th Aug 2022, 6:00 PM #9
💖💕 hate 💘 death 💝 kill 💞💗
User avatar
Dead or Alive
yeehaw. well this looks cute. Chapter 1 was to da point, Clay seems like a lovable rapscallion. Reminds me of...uh... every cowboy plus the guy from Tangled. I am not sure if that is a mask on Blackbell or the shadow of his hat. I am obsessed with how you've drawn the COWS
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 6:03 PM #10

User avatar
_______________________
image
image
7th Aug 2022, 6:10 PM #11

User avatar
Care to take a peek at Dancing with the Dead?
_______________________
image
7th Aug 2022, 6:10 PM #12
Bird Keeper
User avatar
I don't know if you read mine yet, but Cupcake War Machine is right here (click the button featuring the redhead) if you're interested and haven't read it yet.
7th Aug 2022, 6:17 PM #13
untamed
User avatar
your next line will be "--- but I'm already subscribed???"

image
_______________________
image
image
7th Aug 2022, 7:09 PM #14
User avatar
Sure, count me in.
7th Aug 2022, 7:19 PM #15
User avatar
I'll say my improvised comic Hell School. I've done very little (1.6 chapers so far) so it's no real indicator of what the story will actually be, but may as well ask now without waiting.
_______________________
image
7th Aug 2022, 7:27 PM #16
User avatar
Gimme.
There isn't a ton to read yet, because I just started it, but I'm curious to see what you think of my buildup so far.

Alsioh Devosa, if it wasn't obvious. The other one in my profile is dead lol
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 8:31 PM #17

User avatar
I'm in.
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 9:24 PM #18

User avatar
Let's do this!
_______________________
Mysterious Missouri: A saucy comic about humans and monster-folk.
7th Aug 2022, 10:50 PM #19
💖💕 hate 💘 death 💝 kill 💞💗
User avatar
Comfur chan
Kawaii uguu. If I didn't know all these references I would be lost, but since I do know the references it makes me feel special and cool. Gambatte comfur chan

KATRAN
Oh boy there's a map, I hope there isn't a test, people are using are a lot of words I don't know. I'm picking up that there is a lot of lore and backstory and probably a war or something that this kid gets mixed up in. Luckily I understand the language of action and punch. Kawaii uguu x2.

Vápnthjófr saga
Looks like a wide variety of animals in this story. Uh oh furry violence, watch out furries, this story is going to break my heart! I like the full color art style and the way everything shifts from cool to warm to indicate day or night. I hate this wretched moose. Terrible deer. The antlers are where they store their evil.
_______________________
7th Aug 2022, 10:56 PM #20

User avatar
Judge me!!! Please and thank you. uwu (i still need a cool banner for my signature lol)
_______________________
Forum > Critique > I'll read your comic for 5 minutes
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 12